Even the most avid ghost lover keeps a little suspicion in reserve. Some paranormal reports hold up. Others travel from town to town like a cover song. Knowing the difference is most of the craft, and it is why every story we tell in Flagstaff starts with the documented record. Here is how we sort the real local hauntings from the borrowed ones.
The ghosts that show up in every town
As our co-founder Susan Johnson wrote in the book Haunted Flagstaff, every ghost tour in the country seems to have a lady in white dancing across a barroom or floating down a hotel hallway. Ditto the ladies in red. Some of those sightings are credible, especially when the venue is historic and eerie stories are already attached; old bars and taverns full of high spirits do seem to attract the other kind. But when the same sad tale of a woman in white or a murdering bridegroom appears in a dozen towns, the alarm should sound. Not because the stories are lies, but because they may be stretching local history pretty thin.
How do you debunk a ghost story?
Check the national news from just before the sightings began. That is the test Dr. Karen Renner, Associate Professor of English at Northern Arizona University and a lover of the macabre, lays out in the afterword Susan asked her to write for Haunted Flagstaff. Renner has actually studied hauntings, and her advice to researchers is simple: if a popular narrative suddenly emerges around a specific time, say, murder-suicide among newlyweds in 1944, look for a real, widely publicized tragedy from somewhere else. More than one local ghost story turns out to be national news wearing a hometown costume.
What survives the test in Flagstaff
Plenty. Flagstaff's darkest stories are documented: the 1937 Walkup family tragedy that Susan researched for a separate book, the Emerson School janitor who murdered his family, the bank robber who bled out in the Monte Vista's cocktail lounge. That is why our answer to whether you will see a ghost on tour is an honest "probably not": the history does not need embellishing to keep you up at night. If you want the full research toolkit, get a copy of Haunted Flagstaff and read Renner's afterword yourself.
Questions people ask
Are the stories on Flagstaff ghost tours true?
The history is documented; the hauntings are reported. On our tours the names, dates, and crimes come from newspapers, archives, and Susan Johnson's published research, and when a claim cannot be verified, we say so out loud rather than dress it up.
Why do so many towns have identical ghosts?
Because grief and news travel. Shared mythologies form around universal losses, and widely publicized tragedies of the past seeded similar stories in towns that read the same papers. That is Renner's argument, and it explains a lot of wandering white ladies.
Hear the vetted versions
The stories that survive the research make up the Flagstaff Haunted History Tour, 75 minutes through downtown, nightly at 7 PM plus 8 PM Fridays and Saturdays, $29 for adults. Skepticism is welcome; it usually lasts about six blocks.
Keep reading
Boo.
